Amid continued strain in India-US trade relations, US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has renewed criticism of India’s trade practices, accusing the country of protectionism and unfair treatment of American goods. The focus of this criticism centers on India’s trade policies and their impact on US exports. Lutnick defended President Donald Trump’s steep tariffs on India, warning that New Delhi risks economic isolation if it fails to open its markets to US exports. Lutnick’s comments, made on September 13, come at a sensitive time for India-US relations, with trade talks frequently stalling over key disagreementsโparticularly tariffs and agricultural exports. His strong stance highlights the significant challenges facing bilateral trade negotiations.
Lutnick’s Criticism of India’s Trade Practices
“India brags about having 1.4 billion people but won’t buy even a bushel of American corn,” Lutnick remarked during a press conference. “They sell everything to us but won’t open their markets. They put tariffs on everything. It’s not fair or reciprocal.” This statement encapsulates Lutnick’s central argument: that India’s trade practices are not equitable and hinder American exports. He directly criticizes India’s protectionist policies, arguing that they contradict the nation’s self-image as a rising global power and free-market democracy. Lutnick’s comments underscore the deep-seated disagreements between the two nations regarding trade policy.
Tariffs and Trade Imbalances
Defending the imposition of 50% tariffs on Indian goods โ including an extra 25% levy on Russian crude oil imports โ Lutnick reiterated that the Trump administration’s strategy was aimed at correcting long-standing trade imbalances. He emphasized that the tariffs are a response to what the US administration perceives as unfair trade practices by India. The significant tariffs imposed on Indian goods clearly demonstrate the seriousness with which the US is addressing these imbalances. Lutnick’s justification for these tariffs rests on the claim that they are necessary to achieve “fair and reciprocal trade.” This approach highlights the ongoing tension surrounding trade negotiations and the pursuit of balanced economic relations.
US Stance and Future Negotiations
Lutnick added that the US remains open to engagement, but not without concessions from India. “Either support the dollar, support your biggest client โ the American consumer โ or pay the 50% tariff. Let’s see how long that lasts,” Lutnick told in a separate interview. This statement suggests that the US is prepared to negotiate, but only if India makes significant changes to its trade policies. The ultimatum-like tone reflects the heightened tension and the pressure being exerted on India to adjust its trade practices. Lutnick’s remarks suggest that significant policy shifts are necessary if further hurdles in trade talks are to be avoided. The US stance remains firm on its demands for more reciprocal trade relations.
Background
India has consistently labelled the US tariffs as “unfair, unjustified, and unreasonable”, especially concerning energy procurement, which it argues is driven by national interest and global market dynamics. Lutnick further criticised India’s self-image as a rising global power and free-market democracy, saying its protectionist policies contradict that image. He claimed that while US markets remain open, India continues to block American access, particularly in agriculture. His remarks follow media reports that the US is urging G7 and EU nations to consider imposing 100% tariffs on imports from both India and China, signalling escalating tensions. While President Trump has acknowledged that his tariff policies have strained ties with India, he has maintained that such measures are necessary to achieve “fair and reciprocal trade.”
What’s next
As negotiations remain gridlocked, Lutnick’s harsh rhetoric suggests that trade talks could face further hurdles unless significant policy shifts are made. The ongoing tension and strong statements from both sides suggest that the path toward resolving these trade disputes will be challenging and require significant concessions from both India and the United States. The escalating tensions and the involvement of other global powers highlight the complexity of the situation and the potential for wider ramifications. The future of India-US trade relations remains uncertain, contingent on whether both sides can find common ground and reach a mutually beneficial agreement.
- Lutnick criticized India’s protectionist policies.
- He defended the 50% tariffs on Indian goods.
- Trade talks are frequently stalling.
- The US is urging G7 and EU nations to consider imposing tariffs on imports from India and China.
- President Trump has acknowledged strained ties with India due to tariffs.
[Source](http://www.en.etemaaddaily.com/world/international/us-commerce-secretary-howard-lutnick-backs-tariff-policy-says-india-wont-buy-even-a-bushel-of-corn:181694)
